For years, large and deeply questionable sums of money flowed unhindered through Danske Bank’s branch in Estonia.
Throughout 2017 and 2018, Berlingske has uncovered, piece by piece, what is now one of the biggest banking scandals in Danish history - the money laundering at Danske Bank.
The case reached its zenith in the autumn of 2018 when Danske Bank presented its own report on the case, compiled by a law firm.
The bank’s CEO, Thomas Borgen, is now history, while Ole Andersen has also signalled his intent to step down as chairman of the board. And with this report it is now clear that the Danske Bank money-laundering scandal is one of the biggest ever seen in the world.
Below is an overview of how the case has developed, with links to central articles.
You may also view this online narrative on the money-laundering scandal to help you grasp the key issues in the case (in Danish).
Massive money laundering through Danske Bank and Nordea
The first chapter in the money-laundering scandal started in March 2017, when Berlingske joined with the journalism organisation OCCRP, Russian daily Novaya Gazeta and other media outlets to reveal how substantial amounts of money had passed unhindered through Danske Bank Estonia and rival bank Nordea in Copenhagen without these banks verifying the clients and transactions involved as required by international anti-money laundering rules.
Berlingske later uncovered how the same two Danish banks also appeared to have played a role in two spectacular international crime cases involving money laundering and corruption in Russia and Italy.
It further emerged that Danish authorities received a detailed warning as early as 2013 from a reputable British law firm concerning money laundering through these Danish banks.
Dictatorship channelled money through Danske Bank
The next chapter of the money-laundering case began in September 2017, when Berlingske dug deeper into client files from Danske Bank Estonia to reveal that the Azerbaijani regime had used accounts in Danske Bank Estonia to channel money to European politicians and officials, as well as to tax shelters and to pay for luxury consumption.
While other banks – including a small Italian savings bank – flagged and responded to some of these suspicious money transactions, Danske Bank apparently overlooked a whole string of obvious signs of money laundering.
These revelations followed a leak of data to Berlingske which was subsequently shared with a number of other media organisations. The stories that came from the cooperation was dubbed the »Azerbaijani Laundromat«.
The revelations led Danske Bank’s CEO Thomas Borgen to launch a thorough review of the money-laundering scandal in September 2017, as the extent now appeared to be »worse than feared.«
French authorities brought preliminary charges against Danske Bank for a direct link to the major Danish Bank’s involvement in money laundering in October 2017 but later Danske Bank changed status to witness.
What did the bank know?
It was subsequently revealed by Berlingske that Danske Bank’s management in both Estonia and Copenhagen had received strong early warnings on suspected money laundering in the Estonian branch – and that the top management in Copenhagen had even been warned by the bank’s own internal auditor that staff at the branch were wittingly and actively hiding shady clients from authorities.
Berlingske also revealed how Thomas Borgen, the Chief Executive of Danske Bank, was briefed on the money-laundering issues at the bank’s Estonian branch at a far earlier stage than he had previously indicated.
Despite these warnings in both 2013 and 2014, it took the bank more than 18 months to clear out the suspicious clients in Estonia.
Not until late 2015 did the bank finally shut down the problematic portfolio of clients. By then the bank had received a reprimand from Estonian regulators for dragging its feet.
Both the Danish financial regulator, Finanstilsynet, and Danske Bank’s own legal department were aware of suspicious Russian clients at the Estonia branch as early as the beginning of 2012 when the questionable money flows were at their peak.
Links to Putin family and FSB
The case has since also been shown spectacularly to be linked to the power elite in Vladimir Putin’s Russia.
One of the earliest warnings sent to Danske Bank’s top management came in December 2013 from an executive with the bank who alerted the executive board to suspected breaches of anti-money laundering rules in the Estonian branch.
According to this whistleblower, a number of companies with accounts in the branch were allegedly controlled by »the Putin family and the FSB,« the latter being the Russian intelligence service.
The whistleblower’s alert was sent to four highly placed executives in Danske Bank.
Subsequently, the Danish financial regulator also started looking into the case, though only after the head of the regulator, Henrik Ramlau-Hansen, had declared a conflict of interest in the case due to having been a member of Danske Bank’s executive board with direct responsibility for anti-money laundering controls at the time when the suspected breaches occurred.
And while Dansk Bank’s management consistently maintained that the Estonian branch was only »a tiny part« of the bank’s total operations, Berlingske was now able to document that it was actually a money machine.
Banking head exits, regulator reprimands
In April 2018 Lars Mørch resigned as head of Business Banking and International Banking - including the Baltic region – since 2012.
In May 2018 the financial regulator, Finanstilsynet, levelled unprecedented criticism at Danske Bank’s handling of the money-laundering issues.
On the same day that the regulator published its strongly worded criticism of Danske Bank’s money-laundering controls, the regulator’s chairman, Henrik Ramlau-Hansen, also publicly resigned from his post.
The scandal grows; the police step in
In June 2018, Berlingske cooperated with television news programme DR 21Søndag and exposed yet another spectacular case with links to Danske Bank, revealing how the scandal-hit Estonian branch had previously been linked to a shady criminal case in 2009 – this time involving the sale of illegal arms from North Korea.
These new revelations led Rasmus Jarlov, the recently appointed Danish minister for business and growth, to criticise Danske Bank’s handling of the case in very sharp terms.
Berlingske then revealed that the suspicious money flows through Danske Bank’s scandal-hit Estonian branch appeared to be far more extensive than previously estimated.
Hot on the heels of that story, American-British financier Bill Browder reported Danske Bank to the police in both Denmark and Estonia.
Major repercussions and an avalanche of events
On 19 September, 2018, Danske Bank presented a report compiled by law firm Bruun & Hjejle into the case at an historic press briefing. Across some 90 pages, the findings document a string of breaches and money laundering of astronomical proportions. Thomas Borgen also resigned as Chief Executive.
But the findings still leave a number of questions unanswered, including where all the money that flowed through Danske Bank actually went.
It also remains clear that the money-laundering scandal has reopened old wounds at Danske Bank’s headquarters in central Copenhagen, as the bank’s previous top management now faces further stains on an already badly tarnished reputation.
Following the findings of the law firm’s report, the case has taken an explosive turn of events:
- The insider whistleblower at Danske Bank, British citizen Howard Wilkinson, stepped forward to speak to Berlingske.
- U.S. authorities have opened a formal investigation into the case, which may result in heavy fines for Danske Bank.
- The Danish financial regulator fears a tide of clients leaving, shares dipping and substantial fines for Danske Bank, prompting the regulator to ask the bank to further bolster its finances. These fears sent the Danske Bank stock crashing dramatically.
- The European Commission asked the European Banking Authority to investigate whether Danish and Estonian regulators lived up to their responsibility.
- Danske Bank’s external auditors are also now in the firing line.
- A string of top managers has left Danske Bank as a consequence of the scandal.
According to the financial news site Finans.dk, Dansk Bank has now lined up Jacob Aarup-Andersen as its new Chief Executive.
Most recently, an internal memo obtained by the Financial times has thrown new light on controversial transactions at the Estonian branch which would be of particular interest to U.S. authorities. These involve so-called »mirror trades« which were uncovered by Berlingske as far back as November 2017.
The latest avalanche of events in the case has also left observers completely bewildered:
»Right now, we are telling investors that we have no idea what is going on in this case and to use caution before investing in Danske Bank. The only thing this money-laundering case has taught us is that it remains completely unpredictable,« one stock analyst told Berlingske.
More stories from Berlingske’s investigative team are available here (in Danish).
Translation: Bibi Christensen